As developers, we want an easier life. We worry and fear of unstable client requirements. We think of any possible ideas the client might come up with, and implement hooks for them in our current code (as long as they are not too tough, and even that is relative to a developer's skill).
Half the time, we are right, and we felt good about saving ourselves a lot of hell by putting in the hooks early.
The other half, the requirements never come. But we still felt good because we WILL be saving ourselves a lot of hell by putting in the hooks early.
But in general? The extensions and hooks we introduced made the system more complex. Code does not read that naturally, hidden within implementations of Template Pattern, nested one within another. The runtime structure of an application is so remotely different from the static structure of an application (class diagrams), that documentation no longer seem to be useful. In fact, they seem to be talking about totally different applications! The growing unnecessary hooks only add to more documentation, which seemed to scare every other developer away except yourself. And we wonder why.
But what could be worse? Well, that the requirements for a new feature came. And it is totally in conflict with the hook we planned. Well, we could argue that the hook was not well designed, and some change would be necessary, and then we could wait for the 'real' requirements to come. So for now, we add a hook to the hook, happy that we have added even more flexibility. And while we are at it, we thought of another possible client requirement. So we add another hook too.
And the story goes on. Hooks on hooks on hooks. on hooks. Half of them probably would never be used.
So what exactly went wrong? Obviously, the problem is us.
We tried to act like we are the client. Except we are not. We are probably the worse candidate to act like the client, since in most cases we are developing for a problem domain of which we are neither expert, nor even remotely familiar with.
Which is why as developers, we should always keep our solution simple. A simple solution is a flexible solution. Add hooks only if the actual client requirement comes. The value added service we provide here is faster delivery of solution, instead of a monolith and extensible solution but would require months to add new features.
Remember, in most cases the clients are the domain experts, not us. They may not always know what they want, but they do know what they do day-to-day. Spend time with them, understand their need. Do not give in to their desires. And do not give them something that they do not need.
Posts
